The Czech president Vaclav Klaus strongly criticized the EU during his speech an the European Parliament last Thursday. His fearless speech was greeted by an applause of many but also by disapproving boos by other members of the EP (see the 1st YouTube video bellow) . Believe it or not, but some of these oposers even demonstratively left the room! Why did people have such a passionate response? The main points of his speech are given bellow:
- “The EU is a revolutionary experiment which tries to improve the decision making in Europe by having its significant part transferred from individual states to European institutions”.
- “The current economic system of the EU suppresses competitive market and constantly strengthens the centralized economy”
- “The EU creates a great distance (and not just geographical distance) between the people and the political representatives of the EU; this distance is much greater than the one existing in the EU countries themselves”
- As far as the just-approved Lisbon treaty goes: “I am afraid that the attempts to speed up the process of integration together with shifting the decisions of the lives of the EU citizens on the EU level may threaten all of the good things that have been achieved in Europe in the past 50 years”
According to the Ceske Noviny poll, 63% of the voters agree with Vaclav Klaus’ speech, whereas 33% think his word were provoking, hurting the Czech Republic’s image. What do you think?
If you would like to review the politics behind the Czech EU presidency and about the Lisbon treaty I found a user-friendly video on YouTube that will give you some kind of an understanding about these issues. Just click the play button bellow (2nd video):
CZ: President Vaclav Klaus ve ctvrtek na pude Evropskeho parlamentu tvrde kitizoval soucasny stav Evropske unie. Jeho nebojacny proslov byl odmenen zcasti vasnivym potleskem a zcasti znechucenym bucenim (video dole). Cast nespokojenych europoslancu behem Klausova projevu na protest dokonce i opustila samotnou jednaci mistnost. Nize je uvedena osnova tech nejdulezitejsich bodu presidentova proslovu (jestlize mate zajem si precist cely projev, kliknete zde):
1. “EU je v podstate revolucnim experimentem, ktera se snazi udelat rozhodovani v Evrope lepsi tim, ze se jeho vyznamna cast presune z jednotlivych statu do celoevropskych instituci”
2. “Soucasny ekonomicky system unie potlacuje trh a nepretrzite posiluje centralni rizeni ekonomiky”
3. “Mezi obcany a predstaviteli unie je navic vzdalenost, a to nejenom v zemepisnem slova smyslu, ktera je v podstate vetsi, nez je tomu uvnitr jednotlivych clenskych zemi”
4. Klaus take kritizuje ve stredu schvalenou Lisabonskou smlouvu: “Obavam se, ze pokusy integraci dale urychlovat a prohlubovat a rozhodovani o podminkach zivota obcanu clenskych zemi ve stale vetsi mire posouvat na evropskou uroven, mohou svymi dusledky ohrozit vsechno pozitivni, co bylo za posledni pulstoleti v Evrope dosazeno,” doplnil.
Podle ankety Ceskych novin 63% ctenaru s Klausovym proslovem souhlasi, zatimco 33% si mysli, ze jeho vystopeni bylo po vsech strankach provokativni a Ceske republice uskodilo. Co si myslite vy?
Czech president gets booed at:
Overview of the Czech EU presidency:
Source:
http://www.ceskenoviny.cz/eu/parlament/zpravy/klaus-v-ep-tvrde-kritizoval-eu-nekteri-europoslanci-odesli/361289
If you liked this post buy me a coffee! (Suggested:$3 a latte $8 for a pound) Thanks!
I agree with Vaclav Klaus completely. Now, is that poll just for the Czech Republic or for all of Europe? But it’s good to know 63% is with President Klaus.
Luboš Motl agrees too:
http://motls.blogspot.com/2009/02/meps-boo-klauss-call-for-free-speech-in.html
I’m surprised you haven’t discovered his blog yet Tanja!
OK so I just wrote this long post and it got erased (I hate that). This is what I was saying:
Yes the polls are just for the Czech Republic
And I do agree with Klaus on many points; what I like about him is that he is not afraid to be the opposition – to disagree with the majority (that’s a healthy sign of a working democracy, right?). What surprised me, however,is that the other EP members could not be polite enough to sit in their seats and hear him out; that shows you how close-minded they are (and rude).
I am going to check out that blog now 🙂
Dear Tanja, thanks for pointing out your website to me, it’s very cute. I would be reading it, especially if I were still in the U.S.
It’s hard to dislike a pretty Czech woman who has also spent a decade in the U.S. 😉
Your video with Klaus’s speech in Brussels looks even more dramatic than the videos I saw: it’s like a velvet revolution rally with Mr Štěpán. Needless to say, I think that Klaus is right.
Hi Lubos,
so you are in Czech now! How do you keep such a great English?
I am not SO in tune with the Czech politics so I cannot say that he is right but from what I have read it looks like he does raise some very good points.
Dear Tanja,
thanks for your compliments. My English, especially the spoken form, remained an idiosyncratic version of Czenglish throughout the decade I spent in the U.S. But on the other hand, I don’t plan to forget what I knew back then.
Best wishes
Lubos
Hey, a lot of people in this world speak English but not very many of them speak Czenglish!! We should feel proud and special!!